From Lochnaw to Manitoulin - A Review 

From Lochnaw to Manitoulin - A Review this book details through a soldier's diary a trip from Penetanguishene to Manitoulin Island in 1839.

Old newspapers and government records provide historians with valuable information. But when historians want to put a personal perspective to their research there is nothing like finding an old diary or journal to discover the attitudes and sentiments of the people who lived during a particular era. 

This past week I discovered a wonderful book called From Lochnaw to Manitoulin, which was edited by Durham native and now Owen Sound resident, Scott Mclean. From Lochnaw to Manitoulin is an edited excerpt from the diary of Lieut. Andrew Agnew of Lochnaw, Scotland.

Agnew was an officer in the 93rd Highland Regiment serving in Upper Canada. In the summer of 1839, he was given a two month leave to travel to Manitoulin Island to witness the "gift giving" ceremony. This ceremony was an annual event when the colonial government bestowed gifts upon the natives who lived in the Great Lakes area. 

The British government gave gifts that included copper kettles, rifles, knives, gunpowder, shot and clothes not only to maintain a peaceful co-existence with the natives, but also to ensure their military support if necessary, 

Although this book does not deal specifically with the Grey and Bruce region, it contains information which is not only interesting but also informative with regards to a better understanding of what the early settlers to this region may have faced when they arrived here in the decade following Agnew's adventure. 

Agnew left Toronto on July 19, 1839, by coach, following the same route that would bring many pioneers to the settlement that would become Owen Sound. 

The diary describes each leg of that trek in detail, including the time spent each day traveling. For instance, on that first day of the journey their coach traveled 36 miles in 8 hours and 40 minutes. 

The next day, after a short coach ride, the Agnew party boarded a steamer. Their trip across Lake Simcoe took them to Barrie and on to Lake Couchiching. After spending the night aboard the vessel they canoed the Severn River. Two more days of paddling and hiking brought them to Penetanguishene. 

On July 26, they left Penetanguishene in six canoes and paddled through the maze of islands that dot the eastern shoreline of Georgian Bay. 

The book details the rigours of the journey and provides the reader with insight into what the Georgian Bay region looked like during that era including the abundance of wild life in the area. 

Agnew's diary provides the reader with details with the regards to the natives, as well as a detailed description of the actual "gift giving" ceremony. 

After his visit to Manitoulin Agnew traveled on to Sault Ste. Marie and his description of traveling the north shore provides us with insight to the rigours which travellers from this region faced when they sailed the same waters only a decade later. 

From Lochnaw to Manitoulin is well-worth the read and is published by Natural Heritage Press.

A version of this story first appeared in my Local History column in the Owen Sound Sun Times.

History Pages

Baseball History in Southwestern Ontario is rich, and surprisingly longer than one might expect, actually setting historical precedents!

Census Takers in 1891 Canada faced difficult obstacles to gather the necessary information but the results were revealing then, and today.

The Glorious Twelfth: A Tradition from Across the Pond which served to both unite and divide pioneer communities.

Maple Syrup: A Pioneer Necessity and a trading commodity for indigenous peoples is now a Sunday morning breakfast treat with pancakes!

Paris Ontario: Who Knew this community had such a unique origin and how the local citizens used that history to protect the environment of their region?

Pioneer Christmas: A Family Tradition as told to me by may grandparents who experienced Christmas as children in the 1880s and 1890s.

"Thank You to a Veteran" - should be something everyone of us should think, and especially say, every day!

From Lochnaw to Manitoulin - A Review this book details through a soldier's diary a trip from Penetanguishene to Manitoulin Island in 1839.

Baseball History in southwestern Ontario has very early beginnings and the dominance of Canadian teams in early competition may be surprising to many readers.

History Pages introduces the readers to interesting people, places, and events that I have researched and written about in my writing career that spans more than three decades.

  1. History Articles
  2. History Pages
  3. From Lochnaw to Manitoulin - A Review