Catherine Sutton: aka Nahneebahweequay 

Catherine Sutton: aka Nahneebahweequay was a hero, fighting for her Indigenous rights and those of her family.

All too often, historians tend to look at the accomplishments of the pioneering white community and ignore some of the achievements of individuals from the native community. 

In the late 1850s and early 1860s, a native princess from Grey County received international recognition for her courageous attempt to regain control of her family land holdings. Her name was Nahneebahweequay. 

Nahneebahweequay (translated meaning: Upright Woman), or using her English name, Catherine Senegal, the daughter of Chief Senegal of the Newash Tribe was born in 1833. 

In 1842, as more settlers began to move into the Owen Sound area, Chief Senegal decided to move his tribe further north to avoid the encroachments of white civilization. 

Paradoxically, while the Chief wanted to move his tribe away from the incursions of white society, he bowed to his daughter's desire to further her education and he left her with her uncle, the Chief of the tribe located on the other side of the bay near Leith. 

Catherine's quest to further her education led her to travel to England under the guardianship of another uncle, the Reverend Peter Jones. 

The History of Grey County notes that the Reverend Jones was one of the first natives to convert to Protestant Christianity in Canada. 

After returning to the Owen Sound area, Catherine married an English minister and teacher, William Sutton. In 1844, the Chippewa Indians gave the newlyweds a parcel of land immediately south of Presqu’isle. 

After having spent more than $1,000 to erect a home and farm buildings and having worked hard to clear 60 acres of their land, they faced the prospect of losing their land and buildings. The Peter Jones Treaty failed to recognize the Sutton's ownership of their land. 

Deputations and petitions by prominent members of both the white and native communities of the area were made to the Assemblies of the Canadian colony. 

However, these pleas fell on deaf ears. All looked to be lost for the Sutton family when the property was at a land auction. But these failures did not stem the spirit or the determination of Nahneebahweequay. 

She decided to travel to England and present her cause to Queen Victoria. in 1859, Catherine Sutton toured Canada and the United States seeking support and funds for her trip to plead her case before the Queen. 

In April 1860, she left for England, having secured the final funds necessary for the trip from an American Quaker group. In England, prominent supporters of aboriginal rights hailed her for her courage and crusading spirit. In June of 1860, the Indian Princess from Presqu’isle, met and presented her case to Queen Victoria. 

Nahneebahweequay, later admitted that she had been so nervous that she had forgotten how to bow and kiss the Queen's hand. The Queen made promises and stated that when the Crown Prince Albert travelled to Canada, he would investigate her dilemma.  

Perhaps out of hope and respect, Nahneebahweequay (Catherine Sutton) named her son who had been born in England, Albert. 

When the Crown Prince to Canada, a deputation from Owen Sound led by Owen VanDusen made a presentation on behalf of the Suttons to the Duke of Newcastle who had accompanied the Prince, to Canada. Unfortunately, this deputation was also unsuccessful. 

William and Catherine Sutton ultimately were able to buy back a part of their original land holding, Unfortunately, Nahneebahweequay did not enjoy her new home for long as she passed away in 1865. 

The courage and fighting spirit of the Catherine Sutton, the Indian Princess, who married the English pastor and teacher provides yet another example of the ingenuity of those who lived in the Grey and Bruce region during the mid-1800s. 

A version of this story first appeared in my Owen Sound Sun Times Local History column.

Discover More About the Bruce Peninsula

Getting to the Bruce Peninsula is a relatively easy driving trip. Here are driving directions from three regions to the peninsula.

Barrow Bay Ontario a Picturesque Georgian Bay Community owes its origin to the once-thriving Bruce Peninsula lumbering industry. Today it is a quiet summer get-away!

Bruce Peninsula Lumber History details the impact of the forest products industry on the development of the region.

Bruce Peninsula Lumbering provided the stimulus to develop and grow the pioneer economy on the newly settled Bruce Peninsula. 

Bruce Peninsula Municipal Politics: No matter what the venue, or the issue, seldom is a popular decision made that suits everyone. 

Bruce Peninsula Travel Routes were often a matter of debate because in the early years, land travel was virtually unattainable for settlers and lumbermen alike.

Aboriginal History: Bruce Peninsula has a long indigenous heritage not just for the native nation living there today, but for other native groups as well.

Aboriginal History: the 1836 Treaty made promises to the native peoples of the Bruce Peninsula which did not last long before everything changed again.

Aboriginal land history continues the story of aboriginal land issues on the Bruce Peninsula. How it happened is a point for discussion by everyone.

Settler Impact on Bruce Peninsula Natives was not only from the imposition of treaties, but also from British military plans.

"Half Mile-Strip" Treaty made it possible for a relatively smooth overland connection to be built between Owen Sound and the Lake Huron shoreline.

Catherine Sutton: aka Nahneebahweequay was a hero, fighting for her Indigenous rights and those of her family.

Allenford United Church history details not only some important information about that community's church, but also about one of the founders of this Ontario community.

Colpoys Bay Vista - Awesome! A short drive from either Wiarton or Owen Sound is one of the most magnificent views to be found in the province of Ontario!

Dyer's Bay Ontario: Began as a Lumbering Settlement and today it is a wonderful vacation retreat.

Elsinore Ontario is the southern-most point on the Bruce Peninsula, located about half-way between Owen Sound and the Lake Huron shoreline.

Forest Products on the Bruce Peninsula contributed greatly to the growth and development of that region of the province of Ontario.

Gillies Lake: aka Ghost Lake has a mysterious past as its original name, Ghost Lake, implies.

Great Grey Owls on the Bruce Peninsula was a surprise discovery for ornithologists and others. Sadly, the story of their visit had an unfortunate conclusion.

Pioneer Campers: Hope Bay mostly considered the peninsula untamed wilderness and some of the locals were not about to disappoint them!

A Pioneer Community: Driftwood Crossing, at the southern-most part of the Saugeen/Bruce Peninsula was at the midpoint between the Georgian Bay and Lake Huron coasts.

Pioneer Missionary James Atkey arrived on Colpoys Bay to minister to the native community near Oxenden until a treaty uprooted his parishioners.

Pioneer tourists first visited the Bruce Peninsula in the 1800s and the region continues as a great recreational and tourism destination today!

Pioneer Vacations on the Bruce Peninsula got an eerie start in the Hope Bay region of the peninsula.

Lighthouses  Lighthouses were vital to Georgian Bay Sailing.

Sauble Beach Ontario has seen it all. A fishing outport; a sawmilling centre; and an internationally acclaimed tourist resort area!

Sauble Beach  This popular beach is known as Canada's Daytona Beach.

Lion's Head  Sailors often sought refuge from the stormy Georgian Bay waters in its well-protected harbour.

Park Head  Grand Trunk Railway in Park Head Ontario was an important railway depot on the Bruce Peninsula when in 1894 the first train chugged through Park Head.

Stokes Bay  Welcomed fishermen as their first non-native visitors. Today, if you are a fisherman, you will also probably want to try your luck landing a walleye, lake trout or any of the other game fish that live in the coastal waters of Lake Huron.

Tobermory Ontario has a rich history and, is the northern- most destination point for travellers visiting the world famous Bruce Peninsula.

Tobermory Ontario Tourism is focused on shipwreck diving which has become so popular that tourism has become an important part of that community's economy. 

Tobermory pioneers experienced a life in a community that was anything but the tourism hive of activity that it is today.

A Flowerpot Island cruise is not only entertaining, but it is also very educational as you will see things that you have never viewed before!

Wiarton Ontario  This historic community was a great place to live in the early settlement days and still is a busy tourist stop on your way up the Bruce Peninsula.

Wiarton  had ambitions to Succeed but while success brought them a railroad and other ventures did not have a sweet ending for many in the town.

Wiarton Ontario’s First Newspaper  A catalyst in supporting road construction and bringing the railway to Wiarton in hopes of making the town the economic leader of the area. But disappointment looms...

Wiarton news: 1890s, as seen in the pages of the local newspaper revealed problems typical of today's communities 

Wiarton Beet Industry was to be a great boost to the town's economy. Instead, it left most people with a bad taste in their mouths.

Travel the Bruce: Owen Sound to Wiarton  A wonderful journey from Owen Sound to Wiarton.

Travel the Bruce: Wiarton to Tobermory  Relaxing and historic journey.

Bruce Peninsula  The Bruce Peninsula is a compelling place, with a rich history, to visit. Once you have traveled there, we guarantee that you will return, again and again!

  1. History Articles
  2. Bruce Peninsula
  3. Catherine Sutton aka Nahneebahweequay